Decision Matrix Maker
Use the decision matrix method (scoring table) to evaluate multiple options against weighted criteria.
What are you choosing between?
Add 2 to 6 options
How the Decision Matrix Method Works
A decision matrix (sometimes called a Pugh matrix or weighted scoring model) is a four-step structured way of comparing options against the criteria you actually care about. Step one: list the options you're choosing between (2 to 6 works best). Step two: list the criteria that matter, like salary, location, growth potential (3 to 8 keeps it focused). Step three: weight each criterion 1 to 10 by how much it matters to you. Step four: score each option 0 to 10 against each criterion. The tool multiplies your scores by your weights and ranks the options.
This method works because it separates two questions that the brain usually mashes together: how much do I care about this thing, and how good is each option at delivering this thing. Once those are split, even a slight mathematical preference becomes visible. It's how product designers, hiring panels, and strategy teams structure decisions where 'gut feel' would either be too biased or too contested. The weighting step is the most important - if you give every criterion equal weight, you'll get the same answer as a basic pros and cons list.
When This Tool Helps and When It Over-Engineers
Use a decision matrix for genuinely multi-factor decisions: choosing between job offers, picking a flat to rent, deciding on a university, comparing software vendors, choosing a holiday destination with a partner. These are the situations where you have 4 to 6 things you care about and the obvious 'best' option keeps shifting depending on which factor you focused on last. The matrix forces all factors into one view and lets the maths surface a winner.
Don't use it for low-stakes decisions or strongly emotional ones. Picking a restaurant doesn't need a weighted scoring model - just flip a coin and notice your reaction. Deciding whether to leave a long-term relationship can't be reduced to numbers without making the conclusion feel hollow regardless of which way it falls. The tool also fails when you secretly already know the answer and start nudging scores until your preferred option wins. If you catch yourself doing that, the matrix is just doing post-hoc justification, and you'd be better off being honest with yourself. For simpler two-option calls try the [Pros and Cons Generator](/pros-and-cons-generator) instead.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the difference between a decision matrix and a pros and cons list?
A pros and cons list treats every point as equally important and only handles one option at a time. A decision matrix compares multiple options at once against weighted criteria, so a small advantage on a high-weighted factor can outweigh several small advantages elsewhere. The maths gives you a single ranked answer rather than two messy columns to interpret.
How many criteria should I include?
Three to eight. Fewer than three and you're not really using a matrix - it's just a comparison. More than eight and you start padding with criteria you don't really care about, which dilutes the signal. If you can't get under eight, group related criteria together (combine 'salary' and 'bonus' into 'total compensation').
What if all my options score similarly?
Genuinely similar scores usually mean the options are close to interchangeable, which is itself useful information - it tells you the choice doesn't matter as much as you thought. If you've weighted a criterion at 10 but every option scores the same on it, that criterion isn't actually helping you decide and can be removed.
Can I save my matrix to come back to later?
Yes - the tool auto-saves to your browser's local storage, so closing the tab and reopening the page later restores your last matrix. Logged-in users with a Pro subscription get cloud save across devices.
Related Tools
Pros and Cons Generator
Make a difficult decision by listing all pros and cons, then weighting them to see which option wins.
Priority Ranker
Rank your tasks or goals by importance using the priority matrix method (urgent vs important).
This or That Decider
Can't decide between two options? Let this tool help by asking clarifying questions.